Beer Review: Blacksmith

Feb 09, 2009

This isn't a review for the Oregon brewery, but instead of my new favorite Guinness mix. Six or so months ago I was at a nice restaurant; I asked the waiter if they had either Guinness or Smithwick's on tap (these are my two favorite common beers). I hesitated for about 1/2 a second trying to decide on my food pairing, when the waiter recomended a blacksmith. Upon my puzzled look he informed me that a blacksmith was a Guinness and Smithwick's poured like a black & tan [with Smithwick's on the bottom]; I tried 3 to make sure I liked it.

I highly recomend that both be drawn from a tap, I have tried this at home with bottled, and it's definetly not as good. I would also recomend finding a bartender who actualy knows how to pour properly as it's important. A direct pour of both will still taste good, but is not prefered.

For those who would like to know the proper pour steps for any mixed Guiness

  1. Hold glass at an angle and fill to just over halfway with in our case Smithwick's.
  2. Pour draught Guinness over a pouring spoon or upside-down spoon in a pinch
    • In a double pinch you can also slow the flow control down to about a trickle, letting the beer hit the side of the glass on filling
  3. Let the glass surge and settle before enjoying!

You will most likely not find a bartender who knows what this is unless they are a decent place. I've had this drink out about 2 dozen times in the last 6 months and only 3 places knew what a blacksmith was and only about 6-7 of those knew how to pour. Hard nosed Gusinness consumers will most likely snub their nose at anything other than a genuine black & tan or black & fog, but there are so good mixes out there (as well as a number of very bad ones). Personally I think worth mentioning are:

  • Black & Tan: Guinness & Bass
  • Black Fog: Guinness with a drizzle of Chambord liqueur
  • Blacksmith: Guinness & Smithwick’s
  • Half & Half: Guinness & Harp

Comments

MiketheWaiter

MiketheWaiter wrote on 02/09/09 9:19 PM

Your final paragraph suggest bartenders in a descent place pour beer better. I suggest to you that they are in that better place because they make more money... and better barkeeps follow the money. However, like you, I love guiness (must be my Irish bloodlines!) and have found some neighborhood haunts that have bartenders who know their trade well. Wishing you the best from Indiana, USA mTw
Russell Brown

Russell Brown wrote on 02/10/09 7:31 AM

My version of what a nice or decent bar is has nothing to do with how expensive the bar stools are or how nice the bar-back is. My version of a nice bar has more to do with the quality of service and quality of drink and choices. It's actually with my experience that the higher-end bars (as in price and stature) actually have worse bar tenders unless your looking for a fine brandy or wine. Many times I find these more expensive establishments choose looks over quality!
Translation Service London

Translation Service London wrote on 09/18/09 2:02 AM

this is nice information need to know more
Stephanie Pitney

Stephanie Pitney wrote on 02/26/10 8:09 PM

Appreciate your post! We just saw a Blacksmith billboard & my husband ooh-d and aah-d over the thought of it! I just bought the combination for his birthday. We had trouble with it not separating out though. I poured the Guinness super slow and on an angle. I'll have to try the back side of a spoon next time!
Steve L

Steve L wrote on 04/24/10 7:18 PM

I spent last Saturday at a Scottish festival in Las Vegas and had my first Smithwick's and enjoyed it. My next trip to the beer tent I saw "Blacksmith" and had to try one since that is what I do. I loved it and prefer it to a Smithwick's or a Guinness. Later that night at the New York New, York Casino in the 9 Ireshmen bar I ordered a Blacksmith and the bartended did not know what it was. When I told him I saw him reach for some strange looking silver object. I could not see what he did but after reading your post it must have been a pouring spoon. Now I have to find somewhere around me that serves it.

Write your comment



(it will not be displayed)



Subscribe to this comment thread